A modern reflective story inspired by "The Calling of Matthew" in Luke 5 and Mark 2
Lee Grant was the last guy you would want to see across the table at lunch. He was a grumpy, strong-handed debt collector, working for a big financial firm that specialized in squeezing people dry.
This big financial firm had its fingers in everything: home loans, lines of credit, personal loans, auto loans, and even payday-type loans. They were ruthless, with hidden fees, high interest rates, and more. When a payment was missed, Lee was called to do what he does best: convince the person to pay up before they lose everything.
Continue reading ↓
It is quite a conversation... -- Image created by ChatGPT imaging.
He did not lose any sleep over this.
The financial firm he worked for had great respect for his achievements. As a reward, they leased him a luxury SUV.
Lee lived the life he believed he had earned. He didn't go anywhere without his designer sunglasses, fancy clothes, and top-of-the-line shoes.
He had been doing this job for several years and had become the firm's go-to person.
He was very well known in the community. So well-known that when people saw him walking down the street, they sometimes ducked into the nearest store to avoid him.
Being famous in his line of work could be a lonely thing.
One Friday late morning, Lee was at his desk scrolling through overdue accounts when there was a knock on the door. Everybody knew not to bother him when the door was closed. That was the house rule.
He grumbled, "Who is there?"
A voice came from the other side. "It's your only friend." Then a chuckle.
Lee knew instantly who it was. "Come on in, John."
The door opened slowly as John peeked around it. "Just checking to see if I have to duck or not."
An unusually soft laugh came from Lee.
He pointed at the chair across from his desk. "Have a seat. You usually make an appointment when we get together. What happened? Did your church finally get wise and kick you out?"
John laughed and tugged at his perfectly pressed white collar. "Sorry, no chance of that. Listen, Lee, something is on my mind, and I'd really like it if we could do an unscheduled lunch today."
John McBride was the pastor of a much-loved church nearby. He was well known for his work with people in prison, people struggling with addiction, and others in need.
Lee gave John the stern look he usually saved for someone whose car was about to be repossessed. "You know Friday is a busy day. I'm not sure I can get away."
"Umm, you always tell me Monday is your busiest day. Well, think about it."
Lee paused and looked down at his desk. He thought about all the afternoon lunches they had shared and how they had become a welcome distraction from his work.
Then another thought occurred to him.
John never showed up without an appointment.
Whatever this was, it had to be important.
Lee looked back at him. "You know what? Why not? Let's do lunch today. How about one? Where do you want to meet?"
"Let's go to our favorite hamburger joint. You know, where we can get an overpriced heart attack."
They both laughed.
Then John left.
Lee went back to work, preparing late notices, repossession notices, foreclosure notices, and everything else that had to get done by the end of the day.
Across town, John was helping serve meals at the homeless shelter when he noticed the time. He had already told the other volunteers he would need to leave a little earlier than usual.
When John arrived at the restaurant, Lee was nowhere in sight. That was nothing unusual. Lee was fashionably late almost everywhere.
The host led John to an open table and placed two menus in front of him without asking if anyone else was coming.
John smiled to himself. Maybe they came here too often.
He picked up the menu and started reading.
A few minutes later, Lee arrived and sat down.
Perfectly on time.
Lee's time.
For a moment, they quietly studied their menus.
Lee looked up. "I have a thought, John. We should live dangerously and get the triple-decker cheeseburger. You know, the triple heart attack."
He chuckled at himself.
John laughed. "Not today, Lee. I'm not that hungry or that adventurous."
When the waiter arrived, John ordered first. "I'll have the salmon steak with rice and a small salad."
Lee stared at him as though he had just witnessed a crime.
"Seriously, John?"
He looked toward the waiter. "You have the best burgers in town, and I think my friend has lost his mind. I'll have the double cheeseburger with fries and a beer."
The waiter left with their order.
Lee shook his head. "Salmon steak. Really?"
"Yep. Wanted something different." John paused. "And for your comfort, I know where they keep the defibrillator."
They both laughed.
Then John settled back in his chair.
"So, Lee, I want to talk about something completely different from our usual bantering. Something has been bothering me for a while."
Lee leaned back. "Okay. Spit it out. What's on your mind?"
John looked at him for a moment.
"It's a simple question with a complicated answer. Are you really happy?"
"Of course I'm happy. Why would you ask that?"
Lee sounded more irritated than he intended.
John did not answer right away.
"A few days ago, I sat with a single mother who has two young kids. Life has been rough for them. Their father stopped sending child support, including the money he was supposed to be using for the car payment."
Lee's expression changed slightly.
John continued.
"The car was repossessed."
Lee said nothing.
"I found out your firm handled it."
For once, Lee did not have a quick answer.
He only saw reports.
Account numbers.
Missed payments.
Deadlines.
He rarely knew what happened before the file reached his desk.
"I didn't know," he finally said. "I see that the payments are behind, and I do what I'm expected to do."
"I know," John said. "You were doing your job. And we both know there are people who cheat the system whenever they can. Somebody has to deal with that."
Lee looked down at the table.
"But sometimes," John continued, "the person on the other side really is trying. They are just losing."
Lee was quiet.
"And when that happens, the aftermath sometimes lands in my lap."
Lee looked back at him. "Are you asking me to quit my job?"
"Not at all."
John shook his head.
"I just wanted you to know there is another side to the paperwork."
Their meals arrived.
For a while, neither man said much.
Lee ate, but his attention was somewhere else. He could not get the image of the mother and her two children out of his mind.
He had never thought about one of his files that way before.
Eventually, the plates were empty, and Lee seemed eager to move the conversation somewhere safer.
"Hey, John. Is it true people actually call you Pastor J?"
John laughed. "Yeah. I don't know how that got started, but apparently I'm stuck with it."
"There is no way in God's green earth I'm calling you Pastor J. People will think I've gone soft."
"You're probably right. I like it when you call me John anyway. Keeps the pastor part out of it."
The waiter dropped off the bill.
Lee grabbed it.
"This one's on me, John. It was a good lunch today."
"Thanks, Lee."
John stood.
"And if there's ever anything I can help you with, just ask."
Lee paid the bill and started toward the door.
Then he stopped and turned around.
"Let's trade phone numbers."
John looked surprised but pulled out his phone.
After they exchanged numbers, Lee slipped his phone back into his pocket.
"For now," he said, "I'm happy."
Then he headed for the door.
Lee worked a little later than usual. By the time he finished, he had no interest in cooking.
He called his favorite pizza place and ordered the Ultimate Pizza.
With the pizza in tow, he headed home.
Once there, he turned on the TV, pulled a beer from the refrigerator, sat down at the kitchen table, and opened the box. The smell filled the room almost immediately.
He chuckled as he thought about the heart-attack jokes from lunch and pulled out a slice buried under far too much meat.
By the time he started on his second beer, the pizza was slowly disappearing and his thoughts had drifted back to the conversation with John.
The single mother would not leave his mind.
No one had talked to him the way John had in a very long time.
Strangely enough, it felt good.
For the life of him, Lee could not figure out why.
Then his thoughts went in a completely different direction.
John would probably say no, but Lee picked up his phone anyway.
"Hey, John. How's it going?"
"Quiet evening at home, for a change."
"Good. I was just thinking about today and wondered if you'd like to come to a dinner party tomorrow night."
John was quiet for a moment.
"You know, I think it would be good to see you outside of work. So yes, I'll come."
When it came to throwing a party, Lee knew what he was doing.
This time, with John coming, he decided a quieter dinner and some casual visiting would be better.
His guest list was still a little different from what most people might expect.
He had already invited a few fellow debt collectors, some loan officers, a few barflies he hung out with, and two girlfriends who weren't exactly girlfriends.
As John knocked on Lee's door, a few members of his congregation happened to see him entering the house.
In their minds, that place was practically a work of Satan.
Phones came out almost immediately. Texts were sent. Friends were told.
The rumors began spreading like wildfire.
John was not wearing his usual pastor clothes. He had dressed casually, something Lee had never seen before.
Dinner itself was wonderful. Lee had it catered, and the food was excellent.
The conversation, however, was a little more subdued than usual.
Lee's friends were not quite sure what to make of John being there.
But talking to people was what John did best.
He stayed relaxed and gradually worked his way around the room, talking with everyone one at a time. He asked about their lives, how things were going, and what they hoped the future might look like.
He seemed especially interested in the barflies and the girlfriends who weren't exactly girlfriends.
Part of John's work involved people dealing with different kinds of addiction and difficult circumstances. He knew how to listen without putting someone immediately on the defensive.
There was no judgment in the way he spoke to them.
Just genuine interest.
It was getting late. At least, late by John's standards.
He stood and excused himself.
"Lee, I need to get home and do some last-minute polishing on tomorrow's sermon. Besides, once I'm gone, you all can let your hair down and enjoy the rest of the evening."
He laughed softly.
"Thanks for coming, Pastor J. It was actually quite enjoyable."
Lee paused.
"And yes, I meant to say Pastor J."
He winked as John headed for the door.
Outside, John remembered that he had turned his phone off earlier in the evening. He pulled it from his pocket and switched it back on.
A moment later, it began beeping like slot machines in a casino.
Message after message appeared.
"What were you thinking, going to that place?"
"Are you nuts?"
"I cannot think of one reason you should have been in that house!"
And they kept coming.
Some were harsh. A few were downright ugly. Almost all of them came from members of his own church.
John did not answer a single one.
He turned the phone off again.
His sermon for Sunday morning was already based on Mark 2:13-17, the account of Levi and the dinner that followed.
The more John thought about the messages, the more appropriate that passage seemed.
But now he knew the sermon needed something more.
He added a few thoughts about gossip and false witness, then moved into Jesus' warning about judging others in Matthew 7.
Getting the balance right took longer than expected.
Sleep was going to be short.
Sunday morning arrived quickly.
John headed to church.
The music ended. The announcements were finished. The offering plate made its way through the congregation.
Then it was time for Pastor J's sermon.
As he walked toward the pulpit, he could almost feel the tension hanging over the room.
He looked across the congregation and suddenly stopped.
In the back row sat Lee.
Beside him was one of the barflies from the night before, looking surprisingly sober.
Sitting next to the barfly was one of the girlfriends who wasn't exactly a girlfriend.
John stared for just a moment.
Then he looked directly at Lee, gave him a small wink, and nodded.
Pastor J stepped behind the pulpit.
"What we have here is a failure to communicate."
A few people chuckled nervously.
John began by talking about gossip, careless words, and how quickly people can decide they know the whole truth about someone.
From there, he moved into Matthew 7 and the warning against judging others.
Then he stopped.
It was not a comfortable pause.
John looked across the room, lingering for a moment on several of the people who had texted him the night before.
Then he returned to the sermon he had originally planned.
"Today, we will be talking about Levi from Mark 2—a man most respectable people wanted nothing to do with."
John placed particular emphasis on what happened next.
Jesus went to Levi's house and ate with people others had already decided were unworthy of his company.
Then John came to the line he had been building toward:
"It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick..."
He let the thought sit for a moment before finishing the sermon.
The closing song began, and John stepped away from the pulpit.
Normally, he would have gone directly to the back of the church to greet everyone as they left.
Not this time.
When the final amen was spoken, John walked toward the back row.
He reached Lee first and shook his hand.
"Thanks for coming."
Then he turned to the barfly, looked him directly in the eye, and shook his hand firmly.
"I'm glad you're here."
Finally, John turned toward the woman beside them.
The girlfriend who wasn't exactly a girlfriend.
He smiled, opened his arms, and gave her a warm hug.
Monday morning, Lee found himself thinking about the weekend instead of work.
Something felt different.
He just could not put his finger on what it was.
For the first time in years, he had to work at concentrating on his job. Normally the files, deadlines, and overdue accounts took over the moment he sat down.
That morning, they did not.
Time moved on.
Lee and his friends became regulars on Sunday mornings.
Lee also started a podcast about living by Christian values, even for people who were not sure what they believed. At first, only a handful of people listened.
Then the audience began to grow.
He started writing about his own experiences as well, using the name Matt Barstow for both the podcast and the book he was working on.
Over time, income from the podcast, his website, and other online ventures began to grow. Combined with investments he had made over the years, Lee eventually found himself in a very comfortable financial position.
One Sunday after church, Lee stopped John before he could leave.
"Do you have time for lunch today? We have some good news we want to tell you."
John raised an eyebrow.
"We?"
Lee smiled. "You'll see."
Curiosity won.
Early that afternoon, they met at the restaurant that had long been Lee and John's favorite place.
They talked casually while waiting for their food.
Then Lee leaned back in his chair.
"John, I know I call you Pastor J once in a while, mostly because it annoys you."
John smiled.
"But you're John to me."
Lee paused.
"And I've got some pretty good news. I'm in a position now where I could finally resign from the firm."
John's face lit up.
"Now that is good news."
Lee pointed across the table.
"We're not finished."
The former barfly shifted in his seat.
"My turn, I guess."
He looked at John.
"You've helped me more than you probably realize. I found a job working with a contractor as an apprentice."
He smiled.
"And I'm eight months sober."
John did not even try to contain himself.
He leaned across the table and wrapped an arm around him.
"That may be the best thing I've heard all week."
Lee laughed.
"We're still not finished."
John looked toward the woman sitting beside the former barfly.
She took a breath.
"You helped me too, John. More than I could ever repay."
She reached for the man's hand.
"I left that old life behind seven months ago."
John smiled.
Then she looked at the man beside her.
He looked back at her.
For a moment, neither one said anything.
Then they both turned toward John.
"There's one more thing."
John waited.
The two of them smiled.
"Will you marry us?"
For once, nobody at the table had anything clever to say.
There wasn't a dry eye among them.
Inspired by Luke 5:27-32, Mark 2:13-17
Synopsis:
Pastor J explores what can happen when someone is approached with curiosity instead of condemnation. In the calling of Matthew, Jesus sees beyond a disliked tax collector's reputation and offers him a different path. Lee Grant encounters that same possibility across a lunch table, where a pastor asks about his life instead of accusing him of it.
Tap to read the actual bible passage:
Story of Levi to Matthew (Luke's version)
Story of Levi to Matthew (Mark's version)
Share this story:
Connect With Us
Enjoying these stories?
Please help us keep the lights on, fuel our mission and more...
Why Support UsStay Up To Date
Join the tribe and don't let our stories wander off looking for someone else to read them.
Subscribe